Finance & Money
Insurance Premium & Deductible Break-Even Scenario
Compare two user-entered insurance options across a chosen number of claims and a year.
How the calculation works
Modeled annual cost = annual premium plus the entered number of claims times the applicable deductible. Break-even claims solve premium A + claims × deductible A = premium B + claims × deductible B.
Worked example
Example inputs — Option A annual premium: 1200; Option A deductible per claim: 500; Option B annual premium: 800; Option B deductible per claim: 1500; Covered claims in comparison year: 1. Expected results — Option A annual cost under claims: 1700 your currency; Option B annual cost under claims: 2300 your currency; Option A minus Option B: -600 your currency; Option A break-even claim count: 0.4 claims; Cheaper option in this scenario: Option A.
Assumptions and limits
A simplified cost comparison, not an insurance recommendation, coverage interpretation or claim forecast. Policies differ in covered events, coinsurance, limits, exclusions, out-of-pocket maximums, taxes, discounts, claim timing and whether deductibles apply per claim or per period. Read the policy documents and obtain licensed advice where needed.
Reference and further reading
Read the underlying subject reference. Calculith is an independent implementation; the reference does not endorse or certify this tool.
Related calculators
- Fixed-Rate Loan, Balloon & Extra Payment Calculator
- Compound Savings, Contributions & Goal Calculator
- Conventional Cash Flow NPV & Annual IRR Calculator
- Inflation, Purchasing Power & Real Return Calculator
- Simple ROI & Annualized Return Calculator
Example values are editable. Results are estimates where assumptions apply. Calculations run in your browser. Updated 2026-11-16.